This is a reflection about a
fraction of the book A Small Place by
Jamaica Kincaid . She is originally from Antigua, but now live in the United
States. She shares with us about her experience in her early days in Antigua,
and how it defined her. The book also presents the authors perspective on her
island and the tourist who visit it and her feeling towards her land before and
after it was occupied by England. Even though the text is not physically
divided, the themes are presented in the order i mentioned them previously.
Initially Kincaid starts by giving us
a descriptive tour of Antigua as she thinks it looks through the eyes of a
tourist. She then starts pointing out the things that as a tourist you would
notice and those that stand ignored, all this in a deeply judgmental tone. She does
not sympathize a lot with tourist and makes it clear by calling them "ugly human beings". She uses
this term throughout her book to refer
to the egocentrically, selfish, ignorant, and all around negative perspective
of tourists. The reason why they are ugly according to the author is because when
visiting a place they are there with pleasure as first priority, hence ignoring
all the problems worth noticing around them. She criticizes how tourists would
walk by destroyed buildings that have been destroyed by a earthquake years ago
and get to the hotel and just be enjoying themselves after witnessing so much
need and suffering.
She also explains that when a tourist
travels he is searching to escape the banality of his everyday life, so he
travels to a poorer place with poor conditions, away from the people they love
and the ones that love them, all to be frowned upon by locals. The feeling of
wanting to escape from your life exists in everyone, but not everyone can
satisfy it. This is why natives look at tourists with dislike and envy, because they are enjoying themselves carelessly for once like the natives wished
they could.
"'Oh, what a marvelous change these bad roads are
from the splendid highways I am used to in North America.'” (referring sarcastically to tourists)
In the second part of
the book the author shares with us about how England colonizing the island
changed Antigua and her feelings towards it. She says that after the colonization
Antigua was stripped of their culture and heritage and was given a new one.
England did so well on spreading and imposing their culture that the Antigua
that once existed was no more. Also the English people living in the island
where arrogant and racist, but the natives didn't seem to notice much. The
doctors also had a similar attitude, the treatment their patients received was
very impersonal, and where treated with disgust as if their presence was
unhealthy.
Because of this she
feels as if she has no real identity because the one her country have does not
really belong to them. She wanders if she is more related to either country but
seems confused and uncertain, as she said "...
no motherland, no fatherland, no gods.".
I found very
interesting the psychoanalysis she makes about the motives of tourist for
traveling and find that it happens to be very true in most cases. I am not
convinced that her perception on tourists is fair to the tourists, even though
this may be the case of some, many tourists will take into perspective
everything around them without ignoring the unattractive things happening but
will still hold distance and respect when it comes to laying their hands on
others business. I believe that her
perspective is so negative because she has been through a tough times as an
Antiguan and she resents what the English, whom are outsiders like tourists, robbing
her of her culture.
I agree with your statement that "Many tourists will take into perspective everything around them without ignoring the unattractive things happening but will still hold distance and respect when it comes to laying their hands on others business." Just because she has had negative experiences with "tourists" doesn't mean she should generalize! Nevertheless, I understand where she is coming from too.
ReplyDelete